Peanut Butter Stuffed Brownies – RecipeTin Eats

July 20, 2025

20

Peanut Butter Brownies are nice. Peanut Butter STUFFED Brownies are subsequent stage! With a thick layer of creamy peanut butter neatly sandwiched inside, each chunk is fudgey, chocolatey, peanutty heaven. Any person cease me – I went again for “only one extra” 5 occasions…….😩

Peanut butter stuffed brownies

Visions of a peanut butter sandwiched neatly inside a brownie invaded my goals just lately. I imply, creamy peanut butter and fudgy chocolate brownie. They’re dream-worthy, no?

To make this dream into actuality, ordinarily I’d go straight to my default brownie stuffing technique – freezing a slab of peanut butter which makes it simple to sandwich between unfastened batter.

However, towards my higher judgement, after googling to see what “all people else does”, I attempted spreading the peanut butter on brownie batter, then protecting it with extra brownie batter.

The web is mendacity.

It doesn’t work! Brownie batter is simply too gentle to unfold the peanut butter throughout the floor, and the brownie batter is simply too thick to unfold over the peanut butter! 🤯

So, I reverted again to my ordinary freezing technique and it labored completely. And really easy. Sure, it’s a must to watch for the peanut butter to freeze. However as soon as that’s completed, simply place the frozen peanut butter slab on a layer of brownie then cowl with extra brownie.

What was I considering? Follow what I do know! 😅

PS Sure you spy sea salt flakes on the peanut butter slab. These refined little pops of salt work so properly right here!

PPS Proof of fudginess:

Elements in Peanut Butter Stuffed Brownies

Right here’s what it’s worthwhile to make this. It’s simply my traditional chocolate brownie recipe plus peanut butter. You may also use the flourless chocolate brownies batter – some would possibly even assume it’s even higher as a result of it’s even fudgier plus you get that refined flavour from the almond meal!

1. the peanut butter

Use common peanut butter unfold, the business manufacturers you placed on sandwiches which has salt and sugar added, like Bega, Skippy. Pure peanut butter (or pure peanut butter) which is simply, because the identify suggests, plain peanut butter (plus possibly a pinch of salt), is simply too runny for this recipe and the flavour is extra intense.

If you wish to use pure peanut butter, it’s higher to swirl it via the brownie. I did attempt a thinner layer of pure peanut butter sandwiched within the center however I wasn’t thrilled with the mouthfeel while you get a superb hit of the peanut butter, it’s a bit cloying (as a result of it doesn’t have sugar or salt added like common peanut butter).

Peanut-free alternate options – Something with a peanut butter texture can be utilized (pictured above). For instance, Nutella (recipe right here), Dulce de Leche (do that Salted Caramel Stuffed Brownies!), Biscoff and nut-free spreads, so long as they aren’t runny. Even jam would work!

2. the BROWNIE PART

Don’t be tempted to posh this up by utilizing larger cocoa % chocolate (like 70%), it messes with the fudginess of the brownie and alters the feel in not a great way, edging in direction of pasty and away from fudgy. Follow common darkish chocolate (which is often round 45% cocoa). I don’t even use 50% cocoa chocolate for brownies anymore, I’m so specific about this!

Darkish chocolate – Per ranting above, use common darkish chocolate (US: semi-sweet chocolate), not chocolate with the next cocoa proportion above 45%. Additionally, use chocolate chips or melts from the baking aisle which is made for melting easily, whereas chocolate within the confectionary aisle is designed to not soften!
Cocoa powder – Simply common cocoa powder, not dutch processed (dries the brownie out a bit). Ensure you sift out lumps!
Brown sugar somewhat than white, for fudgier texture.

Flour – Simply plain / all-purpose flour. No baking powder in brownies – makes it puffy and cake like which we don’t need!
Vanilla extract somewhat than vanilla essence (imitation).
Eggs – Giant eggs, that are 50 – 55g every (2 oz) offered in cartons labelled “giant eggs” which can be 600 – 660g for a dozen. In the event you use eggs which can be a lot bigger than this, like jumbo, then it makes the brownies a bit much less fudgy. In contrast to most baking recipes, there isn’t any must carry them to room temperature.

Butter – I alway use unsalted butter so I can add the quantity of salt I would like myself. Please don’t use margarine, the flavour is simply not the identical!
Salt – Only a bit, to carry out the flavours. Fairly commonplace baking follow nowadays!
Salt flakes – Forgot to {photograph}! I actually like so as to add a sprinkle on the peanut butter slab and on the floor of the completed brownie. It provides little pops of salt that reduce via the richness superbly – particularly with indulgent treats like these brownies.

No flakes? You need to use common salt on the peanut butter layer, however I wouldn’t apply it to high. It doesn’t have the identical delicate contact – it’s a bit too harsh.

Tips on how to make Peanut Butter Stuffed Brownies

Shockingly simple – freeze the peanut butter to make a slab that you simply put within the brownie batter. As for the brownie batter? One bowl and a handheld whisk. Really easy. 🙂

1. Frozen peanut butter slab for stuffing

Heat peanut butter within the microwave to make it pourable.
Pour right into a paper lined 20cm/8″ pan then unfold. As a result of it’s unfastened, it’s simple to unfold evenly – simply tilt the pan or unfold with the again of a spoon. Sprinkle with salt flakes, if utilizing – the little pops of salt is a pleasant contact however not a deal breaker for those who neglect (which I maintain doing).

Freeze for 3 hours till it’s frozen stable so you may decide it up with out flopping in any respect.
Take away from the pan by lifting it out with the paper then maintain it within the freezer on the paper till required. Re-line the pan with paper, we’re going to make use of it for the brownies.

2. brownie batter and stuffing

This half is a breeze!

Soften the chocolate and butter within the microwave and blend collectively till clean (I exploit a whisk – it combines them shortly). It takes me 3 x 30 second increments on excessive.
Make batter – Whisk the sugar in first, then add the eggs and vanilla and whisk in till clean. Add the flour, cocoa and salt, whisk till mixed.

Stuff – Pour half the batter right into a pan and unfold out.
Prime with the peanut butter slab (straight from the freezer) and place it on high.

Peanut butter for swirls – Pour over the remaining batter and clean out. Heat the two tablespoons of peanut butter within the microwave to loosen. Drizzle/dollop randomly throughout the floor.

Swirl – then make swirls by dragging a butter knife or again of a teaspoon throughout the floor. Make shallow grooves if wanted utilizing the flat aspect of the knife or the again of a teaspoon to disclose enough brownie batter. The brownie batter companies up as a result of it will get chilled from the frozen peanut butter slab, however it can soften and stage out within the oven. No must stress about this step – be daring and courageous! It at all times seems fairly. 🙂

Bake for 32 minutes, till the perimeters are a bit set however the center remains to be jiggling. It’s slightly longer than traditional brownies (which take 27 minutes) as a result of the brownie batter will get chilled by the frozen peanut butter slab so it wants extra time to return as much as temperature.
Cool for 1 hour on the counter then no less than 3 hours within the fridge to let it set earlier than reducing, else the peanut butter will ooze out. Oh! Additionally, sprinkle with sea salt. It really works so properly right here!

Only a fast be aware on reducing and consuming issues. It must be chilled to agency up the peanut butter layer so it doesn’t ooze out in all places while you reduce it. So it can really feel a bit agency as you chop it, however as soon as it’s introduced again to room temperature it softens right into a fudgy brownie texture and the peanut butter goes creamy.

And truly, although I like to recommend bringing it to room temperature so it goes a bit gooey,it’s actually, actually good even fridge chilly. The feel is extra like fudge, , the sweet sort, the place it’s a bit firmer to chunk into however as soon as in your mouth it melts right into a river of wealthy molten goodness.

In abstract – you simply can’t go flawed with these brownies, nevertheless you eat them.

I problem you to cease at one. – Nagi x

Peanut butter stuffed brownies FAQ

Watch make it

OOPS! Please ignore the step the place I add chopped chocolate into the batter, this was introduced over in error from the traditional Chocolate Brownies video. There isn’t any chopped chocolate in these Peanut Butter Stuffed Brownies! Sorry for the confusion. 🙂 I’ll substitute the video on Monday!

Hungry for extra? Subscribe to my e-newsletter and observe alongside on Fb, Pinterest and Instagram for all the newest updates.

Peanut Butter Stuffed Brownies – RecipeTin Eats

Peanut butter stuffed brownies